Понятие государства в работах М. Вебера и Г. Ландауэра: анализ веберианского определения из перспективы анархической теории

Abstract

The article focuses on the concept of the state in the works of the German sociologist M. Weber and his contemporary, the anarchist G. Landauer. Specifically, it is commonly thought that Weber has a unique interpretation of the state, its nature, and inalienable characteristics. This Weberian approach did not fit into any of the traditions that existed at that time in Germany (for example, represented by H. Kelsen, G. Jellinek, and O. von Gierke). However, the author of the article tries to demonstrate that three main Weberian aspects of the state - 1) the monopoly on legitimate physical violence, 2) the relationship of domination, which is accompanied by a minimum desire to obey, and 3) the chance for the regular reproducibility of these relationships-are consonant with Landauer's concept of the state. This discovered conceptual affinity allows one to look at Weber's sociology from new angles, without being impacted by the personal beliefs of the German scientist, who very critically treated anarchism as a socio-political movement. In the final section of the paper, the author discusses the modern project of "anarchist sociology", which also uses Weberian methodology. The paper argues that "anarchist sociology" might be a promising social science with its unique vision of several key sociological topics, such as domination, power, or social inequality.