Bibtex export
@article{ Gregoire2014, title = {Efficiency in the multinational federal republic}, author = {Gregoire, Jean-Francois}, journal = {Federal Governance}, number = {1}, pages = {24-40}, volume = {11}, year = {2014}, issn = {1923-6158}, urn = {https://nbn-resolving.org/urn:nbn:de:0168-ssoar-440899}, abstract = {The paper is divided in three sections. In the first section, I question the use of the statist redistributive paradigm in federalism. In the second section, I argue that efficiency is a moral principle and that it has a strong normative appeal, especially in contexts of diversity. I show that adopting efficiency as a guiding principle to think of the role of the state, especially in contexts of pluralism, as in MNF, allows us to consider the division of competences in a way that is yet unexplored in political philosophy. Furthermore, I argue that embracing efficiency allows us to avoid the moral problems that other moral approaches encounter, especially as I will defend a non-utilitarian conception of efficiency. That also allows me to show that if one opts for the view that pictures federalism as an efficiency maximizing enterprise, it does not lead to a libertarian conception of federalism. Finally, I try to briefly sketch a possible connection between the principle of efficiency and republican ideal of ‘non-domination’ (Pettit 2012). More specifically I suggest that the pursuit of ‘non-domination’ is totally compatible with the pursuit of efficiency in MNF. In other words, the federal government can interfere to resolve government failures at the sub-unit level, for instance externalities, without being or becoming a dominating agent. The ideal of non-domination supports the sort of strong government interventions defended by egalitarians without having to compromise on the autonomy of federated entities. The combination of efficiency and non-domination ends with a defense of asymmetrical federal arrangements, without sacrificing the equality that states ought to preserve.}, keywords = {Föderalismus; federalism; Mehrebenensystem; multi-level system; Multi-Level-Governance; multi-level-governance; Pluralismus; pluralism; Republikanismus; republicanism; Umverteilung; redistribution; Effizienz; efficiency}}