More documents from Liu, Yangyue
More documents from Journal of Current Southeast Asian Affairs

Export to your Reference Manger

Please Copy & Paste



Bookmark and Share

Crafting a democratic enclave on the cyberspace: case studies of Malaysia, Indonesia, and Singapore

Die Anfertigung einer demokratischen Enklave im Cyberspace: Fallstudien aus Malaysia, Indonesien und Singapur
[journal article]

Liu, Yangyue

fulltextDownloadDownload full text

(external source)

Citation Suggestion

Please use the following Persistent Identifier (PID) to cite this document:

Further Details
Abstract As an antithesis of “authoritarian enclave” which has been well-established in the comparative politics literature, “democratic enclave” points to the institution of a state or the unambiguous regulatory space in society “where the authoritarian regime’s writ is substantively limited and is replaced by an adherence to recognizably democratic norms and procedures” (Gilley 2010). In this sense, the Internet space, embodied by information and communication technologies, has great potential to play such a role, since its “inherited” properties of decentralization and anonymity would inevitably breach the authoritarian rules. However, a closer look at three Southeast Asian states, Malaysia, Singapore and the “New Order” Indonesia whose regimes were characterized by authoritarianism when Internet was initially developed, reveals different trajectories. In the “New Order” Indonesia and Malaysia, the governments consciously left the Internet space uncontrolled; the online media developed independently, vibrantly, and professionally, especially in the Malaysian case; and there were strong connections between online and offline contentious politics. These elements made the Internet space in Indonesia and Malaysia a successful case of democratic enclave. Based on these criteria, however, the Internet space in Singapore has not achieved similar status. This paper analyses the different outcomes of enclave creation on the cyberspace among these countries. It argues that elite conflict and the strength of civil society are the two major factors that shape the differences. In this sense, the political contexts are of great importance for the understanding of Internet’s political impacts.
Keywords Malaysia; Indonesia; Singapore; information technology; democratization; Internet; communication technology; political participation; civil society; transparency; the public
Classification Political Process, Elections, Political Sociology, Political Culture; Interactive, electronic Media
Document language English
Publication Year 2011
Page/Pages p. 33-55
Journal Journal of Current Southeast Asian Affairs, 30 (2011) 4
ISSN 1868-4882
Status Published Version; peer reviewed
Licence Creative Commons - Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works